If you’re visiting Menomonie, Wisconsin, and looking for the best local eats, you’re in for a treat! This charming town is full of hidden gems and beloved favorites, offering everything from legendary pizza to lakeside supper club classics. Whether you’re in the mood for a cozy breakfast, a hearty meal, or a burger with a view, these nine restaurants are where locals go to satisfy their appetites.
1. Ted’s Pizza – A Local Pizza Legend
📍 306 Main St E, Menomonie, WI
Ted’s Pizza is the spot for a slice of heaven in Menomonie. Family-owned since 1970, this Greek-style pizzeria is known for its homemade dough, rich tomato sauce, and generous toppings. Try the House Special or a classic gyro for a taste of local history.
Local Tip: The House Special (sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, and green peppers) is a fan favorite.
2. Wilson Creek Inn – A Supper Club with a Modern Twist
📍 E6007 578th Ave, Menomonie, WI
Wilson Creek Inn is a hidden gem off the beaten path, offering scratch-made comfort food with an upscale twist. As one of Menomonie’s beloved supper clubs, it delivers a classic Wisconsin dining experience with high-quality ingredients and an inviting atmosphere. The menu changes seasonally, but you can always expect expertly crafted dishes and excellent service.
Local Tip: Reservations recommended—this place fills up fast!
3. Waterfront Bar & Grill – Burgers with a View
📍 512 Crescent St, Menomonie, WI
Overlooking Lake Menomin, Waterfront Bar & Grill serves up delicious burgers, wings, and craft beer with some of the best views in town. Whether you’re here for a casual lunch or catching the sunset with a cold one, this is a must-visit spot.
Local Tip: If you’re there on a Friday, the fish fry is a classic Wisconsin experience. Go for the beer-battered cod!
4. Jake’s Supper Club – Classic Wisconsin Supper Club Vibes
📍 E5690 County Rd D, Menomonie, WI
Nothing says “Wisconsin” like a traditional supper club, and Jake’s delivers. Located on Tainter Lake, this spot offers a classic supper club experience with a welcoming atmosphere, prime rib, old-fashioneds, and a Friday night fish fry that’s worth the trip. With its scenic waterfront location and hearty portions, Jake’s is a staple for both locals and visitors.
Local Tip: If you’re there on the weekend, the slow-roasted prime rib is a must. It’s juicy, tender, and packed with flavor.
5. Raw Deal – Healthy, Organic, and Delicious
📍 603 Broadway St S, Menomonie, WI
If you’re looking for something fresh, organic, and plant-based, Raw Deal is the place to be. This cozy café serves up smoothies, juices, house-roasted coffee, and locally sourced eats.
Local Tip: If you have a sweet tooth, their vegan baked goods are delicious and guilt-free. Best paired with one of their fresh, organic juices or smoothies.
6. Log Jam – Craft Beer & Cozy Pub Atmosphere
📍 709 Broadway St S, Menomonie, WI
Log Jam is where the locals go to unwind. With an impressive craft beer selection, juicy burgers, and a warm, rustic atmosphere, this pub is a staple in Menomonie’s dining scene.
Local Tip: Try the Lumberjack Burger—an 8oz patty with pepper jack cheese, BBQ sauce, bacon, and crispy onion slices. Made with fresh, locally sourced beef from Cut Rite Meat Shoppe.
7. Tanglewood Greens – Golf & Gourmet Dining
📍 2200 Crestwood Dr, Menomonie, WI
You don’t have to be a golfer to enjoy Tanglewood Greens. This scenic golf course also boasts a fantastic restaurant with gourmet entrees and an elegant yet relaxed vibe. It’s perfect for date night or a post-game meal.
Local Tip: The Make-Your-Own S’mores is a fun way to end your meal, especially if you’re dining with friends or family!
8. Hang’s Cuisine – Bold Flavors & Authentic Southeast Asian Dishes
📍 541 Broadway St S, Menomonie, WI
Hang’s Cuisine is a hidden gem in Menomonie, serving up a mouthwatering mix of Thai, Lao, and Vietnamese dishes alongside refreshing boba tea. With everything from rich curries and fragrant pho to sizzling stir-fries, this spot is a go-to for those craving authentic Southeast Asian flavors. Whether you’re in the mood for fresh papaya salad, crispy egg rolls, or a flavorful stir-fry, Hang’s Cuisine delivers on taste and variety. Pair your meal with one of their delicious boba tea or Thai coffee for the perfect finishing touch.
Local Tip: The Basil Stir-Fry is a favorite among regulars—packed with fresh basil, bold spices, and topped with a perfectly cooked egg.
9. Cancun Mexican Grill – Festive Atmosphere & Flavorful Mexican Cuisine
📍 1919 Stout Rd, Menomonie, WI
Cancun Mexican Grill is a lively, family-friendly restaurant serving up authentic Mexican flavors in the heart of Menomonie. With a menu full of classics like sizzling fajitas, flavorful enchiladas, and fresh tacos, there’s something for everyone—including plenty of vegetarian and vegan options. The welcoming atmosphere and colorful décor make it a great spot for a casual lunch or a fun night out.
Local Tip: Pair your meal with one of their signature margaritas—the house-made lime margarita is a crowd favorite!
Ready to Eat Like a Local in Menomonie?
From pizza and burgers to supper club classics, Menomonie has something for every craving. Whether you’re visiting for the weekend or just passing through, these local favorites are sure to make your trip unforgettable.
